On March 15th, 2016, at Hanover High School in Oceanside, California, 27 faculty cars at the school parking lot were found with phallic images drawn on them. The school board accuses senior class clown, Dylan Maxwell, relying on a consistent testimony from witness Alex Trimboli, which results in Dylan's expulsion. However, Dylan claims that he didn't draw on the cars. An investigation led by sophomore Peter Maldonado and his friend Sam Ecklund takes place to exonerate Dylan from his expulsion.